Cereal Ratings

Here is our cereal rating guide. All cereals listed here have been reviewed in an issue of The Boxtop. Refer to these back issues for our complete reviews.

Side Panel Monthly Ingredients Cereal Review Feature Articles Reader's Poll Reader's Poll Results What's New in Cereal? Perpetually Updated Cereal Ratings Cereal Ideas Letters to the Editor Meet the Staff Topher Ellis, Editor Links Favorite Cereal Links Back Issues Complete Index Subscribe Free Subscription Stuck in a Frame? Click to Break Free Privacy Policy And Ethics Code Disclaimers And Other Legal Stuff Back To The Top

Boxtop Rating (10 Boxtops is the Highest Rating) 09 to 10 A Classic! Belongs On Every Breakfast Table. 07 to 08 Very Good! Recommend Purchase. 05 to 06 Middle Of The Road. You Could Do Worse. 03 to 04 "We Have A Spill On Aisle 4". Feed it to your dog. 01 to 02 Why Bother. Leave It On Your Grocer's Shelf. 00 Throw away! Atune Foods Cereal Rating Issue Reviewed Attune Foods' Uncle Sam Toasted Whole-Wheat Flakes & Flaxseed (Original) 5 Boxtops Early Spring 2011 by Topher, Editor Barbara's Bakery Cereal Rating Issue Reviewed Barbara's Bakery Peanut Butter Puffins 7 Boxtops Holiday Season 2004 by Topher, Editor Barbara's Bakery Shredded Oats 4 Boxtops Early Spring 2011 by Topher, Editor Barbara's Bakery Shredded Wheat 9 Boxtops Spring 2009 by Topher, Editor General Mills Cereal Rating Issue Reviewed Cascadian Farm Ancient Grains Granola 5 Boxtops Summer 2012 by Topher, Editor Cascadian Farm Fruit & Nut Granola 5 Boxtops Late Summer 2011 by Topher, Editor General Mills Apple Cinnamon Cheerios 8 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Sarah Dean General Mills Basic 4 4 Boxtops April 2000 by Topher, Editor General Mills Cinnamon Toast Crunch 9 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by Sarah Dean General Mills Cookie Crisp 3 Boxtops Late Summer 2005 by Topher, Editor General Mills - Hershey's Cookies 'n' Creme 5 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Terri Ellis General Mills Cocoa Puffs 9 Boxtops Early Summer 2003 by Chris Ellis General Mills Cocoa Puffs Brownie Crunch 7 Boxtops Late Summer 2011 by Topher, Editor General Mills Frosted Mini Chex 7 Boxtops Autumn-Winter 2002 by Chris Ellis General Mills Frosted Toast Crunch 8 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by Ryn & Dana General Mills Fruity Yummy Mummy (Retro) 8 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Eric Smith General Mills Frute Brute (Retro) 8 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Star Smith General Mills Golden Grahams 2 Boxtops Spring 2008 by Topher, Editor General Mill's Honey Nut Chex 0 Boxtops Spring 2009 by Topher, Editor General Mills Honey Nut Clusters 7 Boxtops Early Summer 2005 by Topher, Editor General Mills Ice Cream Cones 9 Boxtops Mid-Summer 2003 by Barbara Ellis General Mills Kix 5 Boxtops Winter 2006 by Topher, Editor General Mills Lucky Charms - "Limited Edition" with Green Clovers 10 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Shaun McCrary General Mills Millenios 6 Boxtops November 1999 by Donnie Neiswinger General Mills Multi Grain Cheerios - Dark Chocolate Crunch 8 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Eric Smith General Mill's Multi-Grain Chex 9 Boxtops Spring 2009 by Topher, Editor General Mills Neopets Islandberry Crunch 7 Boxtops Early Spring 2006 by Barbara Ellis General Mills NesQuik Nestle NesQuik 7 Boxtops December 1999 by Topher, Editor General Mills Peanut Butter Toast Crunch 4 Boxtops Early Summer 2005 by Topher, Editor General Mills Peanut Butter Toast Crunch 7 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Topher, Editor General Mills Reese's Puffs 7½ Boxtops Late Summer 2005 by Topher, Editor General Mills Team Cheerios 9 Boxtops Autumn 2003 by Terri Ellis General Mills The Return of Frute Brute 5 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Terri Ellis General Mills The Return of Fruity Yummy Mummy 6 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Terri Ellis General Mills Total 7 Boxtops Late Summer 2005 by Topher, Editor General Mills Total Honey Clusters 2 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Topher, Editor General Mills Total with Strawberries 5 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Topher, Editor General Mills Trix Swirls 10 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Shaun McCrary General Mills Uh-Gi-Oh! Cereal 5½ Boxtops Autumn 2003 by Terri Ellis General Mills Wheaties Energy Crunch 8 Boxtops Holiday Season 2004 by Topher, Editor General Mills Wheaties Fuel 7 Boxtops Winter 2010 by Topher, Editor Ralston (General Mills) Corn Chex 4 Boxtops February 2000 by Topher, Editor Ralston (General Mills) Rice Chex 4 Boxtops February 2000 by Topher, Editor Ralston (General Mills) Wheat Chex 7 Boxtops February 2000 by Topher, Editor Kashi (Organic Cereals) Rating Issue Reviewed Kashi Autumn Wheat 8 Boxtops Summer 2010 by Topher, Editor Kashi Berry Blossoms 5 Boxtops Late Summer 2011 by Topher, Editor Kashi Cinnamon Harvest 7 Boxtops Summer 2010 by Topher, Editor Kashi Golden Goodness 7 Boxtops Summer 2012 by Topher, Editor Kashi GOLEAN Crunch 0 Boxtops Summer 2010 by Topher, Editor Kashi Indigo Mornings 5 Boxtops Summer 2012 by Topher, Editor Kashi Strawberry Fields 6 Boxtops Summer 2010 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Cereal Rating Issue Reviewed Kellogg's Apple Jacks - Apple Clones 8 Boxtops Late Summer 2011 by Spence Family Kellogg's Barbie Fairytopia Cereal 5 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Barbara Ellis Kellogg's Bite-Sized Mini Wheats 8 Boxtops Summer 2000 by Chris Ellis Kellogg's Cars 2 4 Boxtops Summer 2012 by Dr. Castle Kellogg's Cinnabon Crunchy Cinnamon Multi-Grain Cereal 7 Boxtops Late Summer 2011 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Cinnamon Jacks 6 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Shaun McCrary Kellogg's Cocoa Krispies Choconilla 6 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Corn Flakes 6 Boxtops Early Spring 2006 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Corn Flakes - Touch of Honey 5 Boxtops Summer 2010 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Crispix 7 Boxtops February 2000 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Crunchy Nut Roasted Nut & Honey Corn & Oat O's 6½ Boxtops Early Spring 2011 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Crunchy Nut Golden Honey Nut (Corn Flakes) 7 Boxtops Early Spring 2011 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Dr. Seuss' THE CAT IN THE HAT 5 Boxtops Holiday Season 2003 by Shaun McCrary Kellogg's Dreamworks Shrek 2 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Barbara Ellis Kellogg's Eggo Cereal 8, 2 Boxtops Winter 2006 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Frosted Flakes Chocolate - Choco Zucaritas 8 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by James Proctor Kellogg's Frosted Flakes Gold 6 Boxtops Spring 2008 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Frosted Mini-Wheats Little Bites - Chocolate 5 Boxtops Spring 2009 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Frosted Mini-Wheats Little Bites - Honey Nut 7 Boxtops Spring 2009 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Frosted Mini Wheats CRUNCH - Brown Sugar 8 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Star Smith Kellogg's Frosted Mini-Wheats - Strawberry Delight 3 Boxtops Early Spring 2006 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Frosted Mini Wheats - Touch of Fruit in the Middle - Raspberry 1 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Frosted Mini Wheats - Vanilla Creme 0 Boxtops Early Spring 2006 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Fruit Harvest Apple Cinnamon Cereal 8 Boxtops Early Summer 2004 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Fruit Harvest Banana Berry Cereal 8 Boxtops Late Summer 2004 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Fruit Harvest Peach Strawberry Cereal 9 Boxtops Early Summer 2004 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Fruit Harvest Strawberry Blueberry Cereal 4 Boxtops Early Summer 2004 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Hot Wheels Cereal 1 Boxtop Early Summer 2007 by Barbara Ellis Kellogg's Indiana Jones 6 Boxtops Spring 2009 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Jif Peanut Butter Cereal 7 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Jumbo Multi-Grain Krispies 0 Boxtops Summer 2009 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Keebler Cookie Crunch 5 Boxtops Spring 2009 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Krave (Chocolate) 6½ Boxtops Summer 2012 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Mini Swirlz Cinnamon Bun 6 Boxtops Early Summer 2005 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Mini Swirlz Peanut Butter Blast 7 Boxtops Winter/Spring 2007 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Organic Bite Size Frosted Mini-Wheats 6 Boxtops Winter/Spring 2007 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Pirates of the Caribbean - Dead Man's Chest 7 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Barbara Ellis Kellogg's Pops - Chocolate Peanut Butter 8½ Boxtops Spring 2008 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Product 19 6 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Raisin Bran Extra! 6 Boxtops Summer 2009 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Rice Krispies 6 Boxtops Early Spring 2006 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Rocky Mountain Chocolate Cereal 6 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Chris Ellis Kellogg's Scooby-Doo! 2 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Shaun McCrary Kellogg's Special K - Chocolatey Strawberry 6 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Special K - Cinnamon Pecan 5½ Boxtops Spring 2008 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Special K - Low Fat Granola 3 Boxtops Summer 2010 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Special K - Red Berries 7 Boxtops Early Spring 2006 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Special K - Blueberry 3.5 Boxtops Winter 2010 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Spider-Man (2001 version) 7½ Boxtops Spring 2001 by Chris Ellis Kellogg's 2012 Team USA 6 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by Topher Kellogg's The Incredibles Cereal 6½ Boxtops Holiday Season 2004 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Toasted Honey Crunch 6 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Tony's Cinnamon Krunchers 7½ Boxtops Early Summer 2004 by Topher, Editor Kellogg's Toy Story 3 Cereal 6 Boxtops Early Spring 2011 by Shaun McCrary Kellogg's Trix - Fruitalicious Swirls 8 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by Sarah Dean Kellogg's VROOMS 6 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by James Proctor Kellogg's Wild Animal Crunch 2 Boxtops Spring 2008 by Barbara Ellis Nature's Path Rating Issue Reviewed Kirkland Ancient Organic Grains Granola with Almonds 9 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Topher, Editor Post Cereal Rating Issue Reviewed Post C is for Cereal - A is for Apple 0 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Shaun McCrary Post Cinnamon Shredded Wheat 6 Boxtops Spring 2008 by Topher, Editor Post Cocoa Pebbles 8 Boxtops Winter 2001 by Chris Ellis Post Cupcake Pebbles 2 Boxtops Summer 2010 by Topher, Editor Post Good Morenings - Strawberry and Creme 5 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Shaun McCrary Post Grape Nuts 8 Boxtops January 2000 by Topher, Editor Post Great Grains 1 Boxtops Winter 2000 by Matt Wills Post Great Grains 7 Boxtops A Second-Opinion by Topher, Editor Post Great Grains - Blueberry Pomegranate 5 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Topher, Editor Post Great Grains Protein Blend: Honey, Oats & Seeds 6 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by Topher Post Honey Bunches of Oats with Cinnamon Clusters 4 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Topher, Editor Post Fruity Pebbles 8 Boxtops Spring 2001 by Chris Ellis Post Honey Bunches of Oats with Peaches 4 Boxtops Winter 2006 by Topher, Editor Post Honey Bunches of Oats - Fruit Blends - Peach Raspberry 6 Boxtops Summer 2012 by Topher, Editor Post Honey Nut Shredded Wheat Spoonsize 6 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Topher, Editor Post LiveActive Harvest Nut Crunch 6½ Spring 2009 by Topher, Editor Post Marshmallow Pebbles 8 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by Maddie Post Mini Cinnamon Churros 7 Boxtops Late Summer 2011 by Topher, Editor Post Oreo-O's 0 Boxtops December 1999 by Topher, Editor Post Pebbles - Summer Berry Flavor 4 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Barbara Ellis Post Selects Organic Apple Cinnamon Harvest Cereal 6 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Topher, Editor Post Shredded Wheat'n Bran Spoonsize 5 Boxtops 5½ Boxtops Early Summer 2007 Late Summer 2011 by Topher, Editor Post The Smurfs Cereal 5 Boxtops Winter 2012 by Topher, Editor Quaker Oats Cereal Rating Issue Reviewed Quaker Cap'n Crunch Cinnamon Roll Crunch 4 Boxtops Thanksgiving 2012 by Topher Quaker Oats - Cap'n Crunch's Halloween Crunch (2013) 8 Boxtops Winter 2014 by Star Smith Quaker Oats - Cap'n Crunch's Sprinkled Donut Crunch 8 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Star Smith Quaker Crunchy Corn Bran 4 Boxtops Winter 2012 by Topher, Editor Quaker Oats Life Cereal 5 Boxtops Autumn 2003 by Topher, Editor Quaker Oats Life Chocolate Oat Crunch 5 Boxtops Early Summer 2007 by Topher, Editor Quaker Life Apple Cinnamon Crunchtime 7 Boxtops Summer 2012 by Dr. Castle Quaker Life Strawberry Crunchtime 2 Boxtops Summer 2012 by Dr. Castle Quaker Real Medleys - Cherry Almond Pecan Multigrain Cereal 8 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Terri Ellis Quaker Real Medleys - Peach Apple Walnut Multigrain Cereal 7 Boxtops Late Autumn 2014 by Topher, Editor Quaker Oats Quisp 9+ Boxtops 8 Boxtops March 2000 by Donnie Neiswinger Winter 2010 by Topher, Editor E-Mail the Editor Please e-mail me if any of my links or images become invalid, and I will fix them immediately. I would also appreciate any comments you may have. © 2000 Boxtop Editor Updated 2018 Back To The Top

Welcome to Topher's Castle - A Great Site for Everyone!